Appraisals

📋 Expert Jewelry Appraisals

Know the True Value of Your Jewelry

Whether you just made a purchase or need an appraisal for insurance, our Graduate Gemologist provides detailed, professional appraisals you can trust — available upon request with every Castle Jewelry purchase.

🆓

Free With Purchase

Complimentary detailed written appraisal available upon request with every Castle Jewelry purchase.

🎓

Graduate Gemologist

Appraisals completed by a certified Graduate Gemologist on our staff.

🏆

Trusted by Experts

The go-to appraiser for law firms and insurance companies throughout the region.

📅

Often Same Day

Most appraisals are completed the same day — available at all 11 locations.

35+
Years in Business
11
Locations
GG
Graduate Gemologist
A+
JBT Rating

Our Appraisal Services

🆓 Complimentary Appraisals

Free Upon Request With Every Purchase

Every piece of jewelry purchased from The Castle is eligible for a complimentary detailed written appraisal upon request — your first step toward full insurance coverage.

  • ✓ Free upon request with every Castle Jewelry purchase
  • ✓ Detailed written appraisal for insurance
  • ✓ Completed by our Graduate Gemologist
  • ✓ Free updates as needed for insurance purposes
  • ✓ Insurance companies typically require updates every 5–10 years

💼 Outside Appraisal Services

For Jewelry From Any Source

Need an appraisal on jewelry purchased elsewhere, inherited, or gifted? We offer full-scale professional appraisal services for all jewelry — not just items bought from us.

  • ✓ Available for any jewelry from any source
  • ✓ Trusted by law firms and insurance companies
  • ✓ Walk into any of our 11 locations to get started
  • ✓ Most completed same day (some may take a few days)
  • ✓ Call 859-309-0041 for pricing info

What's Included in an Appraisal

Value Assessment

A professional evaluation of the current market value of your jewelry, backed by training, equipment, and decades of experience.

Metal Content Analysis

Detailed identification and documentation of the metal type, purity, and composition of your piece.

Gemstone Identification

Each gemstone is identified, measured, and graded for color and clarity — ensuring your insurance replacement matches the original.

Design & Authenticity

Documentation of the design, craftsmanship, and authenticity of the piece, giving you complete protection.

🛡️ Why You Need an Appraisal

An appraisal is essential for protecting your investment.

  • ✓ A written appraisal is the first step in obtaining full and complete insurance coverage for your jewelry
  • ✓ Forward your appraisal to your insurance agent to be listed as a schedule on your homeowner's policy
  • ✓ Most insurance companies require updated appraisals every 5–10 years
  • ✓ The detailed description ensures you receive an insurance replacement of comparable value
  • ✓ Protects you with documented proof of authenticity, quality, and value

How to Get an Appraisal

1

Visit Any Location

Bring your jewelry to any of our 11 locations. Include any certificates or documentation you have.

2

Expert Evaluation

Our Graduate Gemologist examines, measures, and grades every detail of your piece.

3

Receive Your Appraisal

Get a detailed written appraisal — most are ready the same day.

4

Protect Your Investment

Forward the appraisal to your insurance agent to schedule it on your homeowner's policy.

💡 Pro Tip: When bringing jewelry in for an outside appraisal, please include any certificates or documentation you have on the items. This helps our team provide the most accurate and thorough appraisal possible.

Common Questions

Yes! Every purchase from The Castle Jewelry is eligible for a complimentary detailed written appraisal upon request. We also provide free updated appraisals as needed for insurance purposes — most insurance companies require updates every 5 to 10 years.
Absolutely! We offer full-scale appraisal services for all jewelry, regardless of where it was purchased. Bring your items to any of our 11 locations to get started. For pricing information, please call 859-309-0041.
Our appraisals are completed by a certified Graduate Gemologist on staff. The Castle has one of the highest ratings with the Jewelers Board of Trade and has been in business for over 35 years. We combine this expertise with continued education to provide you with the most accurate, up-to-date appraisals.
Most appraisals can be completed the same day. On some rare occasions, more complex pieces may take up to a few days. We'll let you know the expected timeline when you bring your jewelry in.
An appraisal is a professional opinion as to the authenticity, quality, design, and value of your jewelry. It includes a detailed description of the metal content, gemstone identification (measured and graded for color and clarity), and a declared price evaluation. This detailed documentation ensures you receive an insurance replacement of comparable value.
A written appraisal is the first step in obtaining full insurance coverage for your jewelry. You should forward the appraisal to your insurance agent to have it listed as a schedule on your homeowner's policy. This ensures that if anything happens to your jewelry, you'll be covered for its full appraised value.
Most insurance companies require updated appraisals approximately every 5 to 10 years. If you purchased your jewelry from The Castle, updated appraisals are complimentary as needed for insurance purposes.
Yes! Please include any certificates, documentation, or previous appraisals you have on your items. This helps our team provide the most thorough and accurate appraisal possible.
Pricing for outside appraisals (jewelry not purchased from The Castle) varies depending on the piece. For pricing information, please call us at 859-309-0041 and we'll be happy to provide a quote.

Ready to Get Your Jewelry Appraised?

Visit any of our 11 locations or contact us to learn more about our appraisal services.

📞 859-309-0041  |  ✉️ thecastle@thecastlejewelry.com

Monday–Friday 9am–4pm ET  |  Saturday 9am–2pm ET

Find a Location Near You