Shop By Location:


Congratulations on your purchase! Having a written appraisal done on your jewelry is the first step in obtaining full and complete insurance coverage. The appraisal should be completed by an expert in the jewelry business. The Castle has one of the highest ratings with the Jewelers Board of Trade and has a Graduate Gemologist on staff to complete your appraisal. Once you have obtained a written appraisal, the appraisal should be forwarded to your insurance agent to be listed as a schedule on your homeowner’s policy. Insurance policies vary greatly so please check with your agent to make certain you are protected. You should have your appraisal updated every five years and The Castle would be happy to do that for you free-of-charge.

An appraisal is an opinion as to the authenticity, quality, design and value of a piece of jewelry. Since it is an opinion that is backed and supported by training, equipment and experience, it is important to understand that there can be honest variations between competent appraisals.

Most people commonly believe that the declared price evaluation is the most important aspect of an appraisal. This is not true! Actually, the most important part (and the most protective to the customer) is an explicit description of the jewelry item and accurately depicting the design, the metal and the stones.

Questions or Comments?

We can help! Whether it’s about an appraisal we’ve done before or something new you would like us to take a look at, our experts can provide peace of mind and information for all types of jewelry.




[email protected]

Make an Appointment

Let us know what time works best and we will be here to answer any questions. Our online jewelry is located at our New Circle Rd store in Lexington, Kentucky but most of our jewelry is not on the sales floor so we will need a scheduled time to have it prepared for you to see.

For same-day appointments, please call Brittany at (859) 309-0041

example: 11/27/17
example: 1:00pm